We’ve updated our Terms of Use to reflect our new entity name and address. You can review the changes here.
We’ve updated our Terms of Use. You can review the changes here.

A Better Person Than I've Been

from Calling Bosendorfer by Nathan Fivecoate

/
  • Streaming + Download

    Includes unlimited streaming via the free Bandcamp app, plus high-quality download in MP3, FLAC and more.
    Purchasable with gift card

      $1 USD  or more

     

about

A faith-struggle song of sorts, it's not fit for church. But what it represents is an honest internal struggle, looking long and hard at one's sin and not sugarcoating it.

In this day and age, the doctrine of sin has rapidly become unpopular, with a new moral code (of sorts) being thrown together, based on feelings, sensibilities, and longstanding personal pain rather than the universal plumb line, the Bible. In an era where, in popular culture, God has been replaced by both science and "personal truth," nothing is considered sin -- except what any given person might feel offended by.

In the Book of Job from the Christian Bible, it records that a righteous man named Job lost everything: his assets, his children, and his health. Although his wife's life was spared, even her role in encouraging him in his faith withered. But Job still had his faith in spite of it all. Then three men whom he had considered his best friends came to try to, in their minds, talk sense into him. During this back-and-forth discussion, Job's heart hardened to the point where even he lost his faith in God.

God finally answered Job's plethora of complaints by holding Job accountable for his many words. "Where were you when I made the heavens and the earth?" It was largely a monologue of God putting Job back in his place, even a man considered righteous who had lost everything. But this isn't a case of God shaming Job for daring to speak his pain after going through unimaginable circumstances; no, this is a case of God reminding Job that he still needed to trust Him, whether in times of plenty or of lack, reminding Job that no matter what happened, it wasn't something that God Himself couldn't also reverse. And, as the history records, after Job completely repented of his words and thoughts, and prayed for his friends who had swayed him away from trusting God, God restored everything back to Job, twice as much as he had had before. Much later, Apostle Paul shared about learning contentment in times of plenty and in times of lack, and how important that is.

This song was written long ago, early in both of my processes of healing and coming to faith in Christ Jesus. I had already grasped the concepts of sin and a God who was Almighty, but I had not yet grasped the true nature of God's goodness and how, in His goodness, He could restore, just like He could take away. This is not a praise song or a worship song, and certainly not a piece of music fit for church. But I sense that there are many people who are currently in a spot similar to where I was when I wrote this song. My hope is that this song encourages them that they're not alone, and that this blurb encourages them that there is much more to God's goodness than they know.

As a succinct backstory: there was indeed a situation in my life at the time that I wrote the lyrics -- a conflict between two people I cared about -- that struck much fear and many emotions in me. With help, I worked through it and was able to recover.

Musical analysis: the chord structure of most of this song is written in Passacaglia form. Even as the sections change, the bass line continues its pattern, with the chords building on top.

lyrics

One night I went to sleep
Thinking about my sins
There's a lot of "no" in me
So hard to take it in.

I sought help so I can be
A better person than I've been
Truth is, I'm so stubborn
Don't feel safe to take a risk.

Truth is, He can't change my heart
Unless I let Him in
And I won't have life to the full
Unless I stop my sin.

In the Book, He says "Where were you
When I made heav'n and earth?
Can you tell the storm 'get lost'
Or make a cow give birth?"

Truth is, I have no such power
And I dare not presume
That I've no sin, nor do I get
To justify myself.

Truth is, my heart needs to change
And quit my foolish ways
But first I need to see it's there
Through my self-wrought malaise.

I will not sit back
And let you beat on me
I have every right, like you,
To fight for my rights, too.

You will not talk to me the same
As you have talked to him
Yes, he's got issues, plain as day
But you scare me more than him.

I'd say you're why I live in sin
But I know that's not true
My sin is mine, and yours is yours
But what about me and you?

Are we cool? I need to know
'Cause frankly, I really don't
I hope you're in, 'cause I want to be
What stops me is your "won't."

I'm seeking help, so I can be
A better person than I've been
But part is that I need you
To be better than you've been
Too.

credits

from Calling Bosendorfer, released December 19, 2020

license

all rights reserved

tags

about

Nathan Fivecoate Chicago, Illinois

contact / help

Contact Nathan Fivecoate

Streaming and
Download help

Report this track or account

If you like Nathan Fivecoate, you may also like: